First Circuit Forces New Historical Test for Gun Bans Tied to Old DUIs
A New Hampshire man's decades-old DUI convictions have kept him from legally buying a gun, and a federal appeals court just ruled that the old legal shield the government used to block his challenge no longer applies.
Snapshot
On November 13, 2026, the First Circuit revived Thomas Marshall's Second Amendment lawsuit over his 1997 and 2005 DUI convictions, which trigger the federal felon-in-possession ban under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1). The court didn't restore his gun rights, but it ordered a lower court to actually run the historical analysis required under Bruen instead of relying on outdated circuit precedent.
Key points
- Old DUIs, big consequences: Marshall's Massachusetts convictions carried potential sentences up to two and a half years, pushing them outside the misdemeanor exception and making him a prohibited person under federal law.
- Precedent tossed out: Chief Judge David Barron wrote that the circuit's 2011 Torres-Rosario ruling no longer controls, citing the court's own September 2026 Levasseur decision applying Bruen's historical-tradition test to § 922(g)(1) challenges.
- Purchase vs. possession split: The court let Marshall's challenge to his denied firearm purchase move forward, but found he lacked standing yet to challenge possession itself, since that claim requires an interstate-commerce showing he hadn't made.
- DOJ's restoration process looms: The ruling flags the DOJ's new § 925(c) relief process, under which the Attorney General had granted restoration to 22 people as of February 2026, leaving it to the district court to decide if that process matters here.
Quick take
This isn't a win for Marshall yet, but it forces the government to actually defend why decades-old, nonviolent DUI convictions justify a lifetime gun ban under the Constitution's text and history, not just old case law. Gun owners in Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Puerto Rico should watch how the district court handles this on remand.
Read the full story: ammoland.com