News

Lawyer Says Connecticut Misreads History in AR-15 Ban Defense

November 15, 2026

Connecticut's defense of its "assault weapons" ban at the Supreme Court is getting a pointed challenge from Second Amendment lawyer Alan Beck, who says the state's historical case doesn't hold up.

Snapshot

On The Reload's podcast, Stephen Gutowski talks with Alan Beck, who recently won Wolford v. Lopez at the Supreme Court, about Connecticut's brief defending its AR-15 ban. Beck argues the state misreads the medieval English laws it cites as historical analogues under the Bruen test, and the conversation turns to how the justices might ultimately rule.

Key points

  • The core claim: Beck says Connecticut's brief treats old English restrictions on weapons like lancegays, steelets and handguns as outright bans, when they were mostly carry restrictions or anti-poaching rules.
  • Why it matters: Under Bruen, states must show modern gun laws have a historical twin, so if Connecticut's analogues are mischaracterized, that weakens the legal foundation for its AR-15 ban.
  • Purpose dispute: Beck argues the state is also misleading on why those historical laws existed in the first place, not just what they restricted.
  • What's next at the Court: The discussion covers how the justices might approach the case given the midterm elections and the chance more AR-15 bans get enacted before a ruling comes down.
  • A second case to watch: Beck says a new circuit split could send another of his cases to the Supreme Court soon.

Quick take

If Beck's read on the historical record holds up, Connecticut's brief has a real problem, since Bruen cases often live or die on whether the cited analogues actually did what a state claims. Owners in states facing or defending AR-15 bans should watch how the Court treats this kind of historical argument, because it will shape what evidence states lean on in future gun-law fights.

Read the full story: thereload.com