Fifth Circuit extends Second Amendment to firearm sales, not just ownership
The Fifth Circuit just ruled that the Second Amendment doesn't stop at owning a gun, it covers buying and selling one too, and that could complicate federal and state rules on how firearms change hands.
Snapshot
In U.S. v. Deare, a three-judge Fifth Circuit panel held that the plain text of the Second Amendment protects firearm commerce, not just possession, reversing a lower court's denial of Jeremiah Deare's motion to dismiss federal dealing-without-a-license charges. The case now heads back to the district court, but the ruling signals trouble for restrictions on gun sales across the circuit, as reported by Bearing Arms.
Key points
- The ruling: Two of three judges found that acquiring firearms is part of the right to keep and bear arms, so laws burdening sales and sellers get Second Amendment scrutiny too.
- What happens to Deare: His indictment for conspiracy to deal firearms without a license and falsifying dealer records isn't dismissed outright; the case is remanded for the lower court to reconsider under this new standard.
- The dissent: Judge Hayne argued the amendment doesn't explicitly mention sellers and said Deare didn't properly challenge the rules as abusive, so she saw no need to remand.
- The pushback: Judge James Ho countered that by the dissent's logic, the First Amendment wouldn't cover booksellers either, calling that reasoning untenable.
- Limiting other precedent: Judge Oldham told the lower court to disregard the circuit's earlier Peterson decision, arguing it wrongly stretched a narrow Bruen footnote about shall-issue carry permits into a broad presumption covering firearm registration and sales.
Quick take
Bearing Arms frames this as a meaningful check on governments trying to choke off gun rights by regulating the marketplace instead of possession directly. If acquiring a firearm is constitutionally protected, then licensing and sales restrictions aimed at dealers can't get a free pass just because they don't touch gun owners directly. Worth watching if you're in Fifth Circuit territory and buy, sell, or deal firearms.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com